If you're not familiar with the OKCupid blog, check out it out here. Christian Rudder slices and dices data from the dating site to try to reveal human nature. I find it great fun to follow along with his train of thought, which he presents engagingly and well-illustrated with graphics. The articles could serve as examples to students of what 'critical thinking' might be.
The report linked above is particularly interesting because it addresses ethical issues. If you look at the comments, you'll see a range of reactions from "that's cool" to "how dare you!", include a couple by putative psychology researchers who mention IRB processes. This comes on the heals of Facebook's research on manipulating attitudes, and the resulting media fiasco.
This is a looming problem for us in higher education, too. As an example, imagine a software application that tracks students on campus by using the wi-fi network's access points and connections to cellphones. This could be used to identify student behaviors that are predictive of academic performance and retention (e.g. class attendance, social activity). Whereas a manual roll-taking in class is an accepted method of monitoring student behavior, cellphone tracking crosses a line into creepy. The only way to proceed with such a project would be transparently, in my opinion, which could be done with an opt-in program. In such a program, students would be given a description and opportunity to sign up. In return, they receive information back, probably both the detailed information that is being gathered as well as summary reports on the project. I have been looking for examples of colleges taking this approach. If you know of one, please let me know!
See also: "okcupid is the new facebook? more on the politics of algorithmic manipulation" at scatterplot.com.
Tuesday, July 29, 2014
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
-
"How much data do you have?" is an inevitable question for program-level data analysis. For example, assessment reports that attem...
-
The annual NACUBO report on tuition discounts was covered in Inside Higher Ed back in April, including a figure showing historical rates. (...
-
I'm scheduled to give a talk on grade statistics on Monday 10/26, reviewing the work in the lead article of JAIE's edition on grades...
-
(A parable for academic workers and those who direct their activities) by David W. Kammler, Professor Mathematics Department Southern Illino...
-
I read Peter Sacks' Standardized Minds a few years ago when I was helping put together our general education assessment process . This...
-
In the last article , I showed a numerical example of how to increase the accuracy of a test by splitting it in half and judging the sub-sco...
-
Introduction Within the world of educational assessment, rubrics play a large role in the attempt to turn student learning into numbers. ...
-
tl;dr Searched SACS reports for learning outcomes. Table of links, general observations, proposal to create a consortium to make public th...
-
Introduction A few days ago , I listed problems with using rubric scores as data to understand learning. One of these problems is how to i...
-
This post is the first of a series on student achievement. The National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) summarizes graduation rates...
No comments:
Post a Comment